Why does an examiner ask, "Why/Why not?" in Speaking Part 1, and how should I answer?
It's not unusual at all for an examiner to ask a candidate, "Why/Why not?" at the conclusion of a response, and it's generally for one of three possible reasons:
- The initial response was a bit on the short side, and the examiner wants to give the candidate an opportunity to explain their answer in more detail.
- The initial response was NOT on the short side, but the examiner would like to evaluate the candidate's ability to explain their initial response.
- The examiner is trying to manage the time. Part 1 must last for 4-5 minutes and consist of 3 sets of about 4 questions (about 12 in total).
Either way, don't think of being asked, "Why/Why not?" as a negative. Rather, you should simply consider it as an opportunity to show a bit more range of language ability, and answer in a sentence or two.
It might not seem like "Why/Why not?" is a logical follow-up question, but it is the only thing the examiner is permitted to say if they want you to talk more.
It does not affect your score if the examiner asks "Why/Why not?"
